As you formulate your course project, posting questions on this page is optional, but may provide you opportunity to get feedback from your peers (in addition to Dr. Dann, if you emailed him alone).
Here's who has posted so far:
Feel free to provide them feedback, if so inspired, in the comments section at the bottom of this page. Thanks!
Misty H's Questions:
I have a slightly wild idea for my project and thought Id throw it out there to see if it would be too wild (it amuses me so much, I had to try).
My project would focus on an ecological thought experiment. Instead of a species becoming extinct, it would mutate. The question is: What would happen if zombies existed. The idea is to show how humans affect their environment and how that would change if they mutated. I think it would be fun to write a short paper and then also make a teaching lesson (in the form of a game) for middle school to junior high students with this fun supposition to get them interested in an ecological subject. Thoughts?
Mike H's Questions:
I'm considering a scientific research paper that examines the impact of grazing livestock on soil quality and plant diversity in national forests where such grazing is allowed.
-OR-
An ecological thought experiment considering the possible implications of the reintroduction of grey wolves to Rocky Mountain National Park.
-OR-
An ecological thought experiment considering the impact of a 1 degree C increase in atmospheric temperatures on the plant and animal life of Shenandoah National Park.
I'm going to go with Door #3, the though experiment about climate change and Shenandoah National Park. My biggest concern right now is whether or not I'm biting off more than I can chew with this project.
Jennifer's Questions:
- My first and most favorite-The short and long-term impact of the recent oil spill of the coast of Louisiana on the abiotic and biotic components of the surrounding marine ecosystem. (and if powerful enough, send it to BP, maybe haha)
- OR- Ecological thought experiment considering the impact of the extinction of the polar bear on the surrounding ecosystem and lesson plan to teach 4th and 5th graders how to effectively conserve energy in their environment to prevent a further increase in melting in the polar bear's environment. ( OR teach the 5th 6th graders the biotic ecosystem of the polar bear (abiotic factors might be a little too complicated for them but its a possibility as well))
- We read about the small shallow bodies of water that exist (like ponds) that aren't deep enough to show stratification with temperature and instead, with the seasons, change to a uniform cold or a uniform hot temperature. My research would be on the adaptions of the organisms in this environment to the change in water temperature that have bettered their survival in this ecosystem.
Honed down to......
My first and most favorite-The short and long-term impact of the recent oil spill of the coast of Louisiana on the abiotic and biotic components of the surrounding marine ecosystem. (and if powerful enough, send it to BP, maybe haha)--any suggestions as to great places to look for this information would be appreciated or any articles you have seen in the newspaper that struk your fancy (as I am not an avid newspaper reader)!!
Kathryn H's Questions:
1. Ecological Thought Experiment: In the cartoon movie "Lilo and Stitch", Earth is a protected planet where the "mosquito population is being rebuilt". So I started wondering... what would happen if the all the mosquitos in the world died off? What would be the impact on the world if this one pesky insect died off?
2. Ecological Thought Experiment: Modern medicine is helping us live longer, healthy lives. What could possibly be the impact on the world if people continue to live longer? Will we have enough resources to sustain life for everyone?
3. Educational Game/Quantitative Simulation: (This is a cross between Monopoly and Life) Each player gets to be an animal (deer, rabbit, squirrel or a bird) and through chance cards, ("Horray! You found a mate!" or "Oops! You got hit by a car!") and rolling dice you move around the board and see what happens in your life. Instead of money you get food and water.
Danielle's Questions:
- First question: I would like to conduct a soil comparison and study for different areas across campus. The soil's quality and ability to sustain life will be the two main factors I will measure.
- Second question: Really my main interest is organic/sustainable agriculture. I am still trying to figure out what kind of project I'd be especially interested in undertaking surrounding this particular topic.
- Third question: I would be interested in researching the negative ecological effects of mountaintop removal in West Virginia.
Total visits to this page:  |
Recent visitors:
|
Comments (8)
Dr. Dann said
at 11:33 pm on Jun 13, 2010
Hi Misty,
The ecology of zombies -- interesting! So, what would make them different in their ecological roles/relations than ordinary human beings? Would they be more or less susceptible to specific abiotic conditions? How would their populations change over time? How would they interact with other species and the abiotic environment differently than plain old vanilla [unmutated] Homo sapiens? I wonder whether they would be better or worse at facilitating the perpetuation of threatened ecosystems and endangered species than their unmutated relatives.... And, relative to humans, would you consider them to be predators, competitors or have some other relationship entirely? Insofar as you can come up with an internally consistent set of ecological behaviors and relations for this new subspecies(?) of Homo sapiens, then explore academically their ecological ramifications, you may have a thoroughly educational yet entertaining thought experiment indeed! Any questions before you die-ve into it? ;) Dr. Dann
Dr. Dann said
at 11:39 pm on Jun 13, 2010
Hi Mike,
I think your grazing idea might benefit from more geographic specificity, such as you suggest with your Shenandoah idea (which I think would be fun, interesting and accessible to research, given our proximity to it). The wolf reintroduction topic has been of interest to several students in prior cohorts of this class. In fact, I seem to recall they may have already been re-introduced, in which case [if I am recalling correctly] you even might look at the actual impact to date. The Shenandoah topic is of most interest to me as I aim to share with your peers [and the general public] how climate change may impact the Chesapeake Bay watershed, including the Shenandoah basin. Of course, it's YOUR interest that should lead the way on your choice of subjects, but I thought I'd share that potential value added if you were to select that topic... I look forward to advising as best I can for whichever topic you select!
Kind regards,
Dr. Dann
Dr. Dann said
at 11:44 pm on Jun 13, 2010
Hi Jennifer,
I share your strong interest in #1, particularly the ecological impacts of the Deepwater Horizon spill, particularly in the context of the impacts over the past 30 years of its eerily similar predecessor, Ixtoc I [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ixtoc_I_oil_spill]. What can we learn from that spill which might inform us of what's to come -- and what might be prevented if we act intelligently hereafter -- in the Gulf now? I am also in discussion with a student from the last iteration of this course about doing a teach in on the subject of DH's ecological impacts this fall. So, your research might result in something we could share with other students and community members at VT and/or Mason later this year. Sounds like a win-win topic to me!
Best wishes,
Dr. Dann
Dr. Dann said
at 11:59 pm on Jun 14, 2010
Hey Kathryn,
I think your thought experiment ideas [#1 & 2] might provide you more opportunity to demonstrate your [soon to be] new-found ecological savvy than a game particularly grounded in monopoly... though you might be able to prove me wrong! On item 1 ("bye bye mosquitoes"), I've been pondering in recent weeks whether mosquitoes might possibly play an ecologically important role for primates' horizontal transfer of mobile DNA(!). To see what I mean, try skimming the following, then read between the lines [of their intersection]:
Gilbert, C., S. Schaack, J. K. Pace II, P. J. Brindley, and C. Feschotte. 2010. A role for host–parasite interactions in the horizontal transfer of transposons across phyla. Nature 464:1347-1350. doi: 10.1038/nature08939.
Xing, J., D. J. Witherspoon, D. A. Ray, M. A. Batzer, and L. B. Jorde. 2007. Mobile DNA elements in primate and human evolution. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 50:2. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.20722.
If this hunch were correct, the removal of mosquitos might even have a negative impact on the long-term mixing up of genes across humans [and nearby species?]... So, that could be a wild take on your experiment (though not the only one, to be sure.
On your second item, What if everyone were Lazarus [i.e., able to live a lot longer], as we explore r- and k-selected strategies in the next few weeks, you may have some interesting new insights on this subject. Fascinatingly, there's also a recent research article about a parasite (see Part IV) which may *prolong* the life of its host (and provide some contraceptive power to boot):
Hurd, E. Warr, A. Polwart, H. 2001. A parasite that increases host lifespan. Proceedings: Biological Sciences 268:1749-1753. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2001.1729.
Dr. Dann said
at 12:00 am on Jun 15, 2010
Thinking of infecting humanity with something parallel in your thought experiment? If so, you might also want to review a short story by Kurt Vonnegut about what happens when everyone can live forever on a planet which cannot support any new people...
Enjoy!
Dr. Dann
Dr. Dann said
at 12:37 pm on Jun 22, 2010
Hi Danielle,
Sorry I missed your list last [sick] week.
For 1, it seems like you might be doing an actual soil survey. Most soil in our region is capable of sustaining life, as you know, but the additives to sustain the sort of life we desire is part of the challenge -- as you know as well as anyone given your tireless efforts on Mason's first community garden. If you were to ask Mason's landscape chief, perhaps she/he has a map of the different types of soil on campus. Given topology and human intervention are likely to be key factors, you might consider analyzing where would be the BEST soil(s) on campus for some particular type of plant community (organic edamame, anyone? native herb or shurb garden? something else?) ... or to assist in the preservation of a specific rare species found on campus -- you can ask Dr. Andrea Weeks for ideas on that native take.
Dr. Dann said
at 12:43 pm on Jun 22, 2010
2. One of the key issues of sustainable ag at the boutique scale appears to be, how can I make a premium product that grows without serious disease, pays for itself, and doesn't require 24-7 attention? Talking to some Master Gardener and/or Master Naturalist in the area might provide some ideas. For instance, I've seen [indigenous?] mulberries thrive on campus -- perhaps such could be upscaled for on-campus purchase/consumption? Other local fruits like passion fruit and pawpaw -- or nuts like filberts or [now hybrid] chestnuts -- are native to this area, but not commercially available. Perhaps you could do a joint, "what could grow here with enough bounty to sell and be profitable" study?)
3. This is probably the easiest to do through a literature review. If you decide to look at Mountaintop removal, there's a wealth of popular and scientific literature out there related to ecological impacts. I'd be happy to make some recommendations if you end up selecting this option. Just let me know.
Good luck!
Dr. Dann
Jennifer said
at 6:18 pm on Jul 21, 2010
I love your idea misty! Wish I had thought of something that creative. As judging by your abstract, I feel that you will accurately cover the topic, and make it applicable to younger children as well. As all these movies lately predict, will we be faced with a cannibalistic infectious disease in the future? Time permitting, I'm sure that some type of game with the perspective of zombies could be employed. One may not even need to incorporate zombies but use it as a perspective for the students to build their ideas on. From there, maybe they could really assess the good (and bad things) we do to our environment. Certain take home hints could also be used to help children learn about their individual ecological footprint like tips on how to recycle etc. I feel that for the time we have to do this project, that an incorporation with zombies might be easier than addressing the topic of protecting the environment. Maybe randomly hand out impacts on environment of zombies and humans and have the students place them in categories on the board? Work in teams? Hope this helps!
You don't have permission to comment on this page.